Half Life 2: Episode 1

General Info

  • Reviewer: POBmaestro
  • Review Posted: 03/04/2008
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: FPS
  • Publisher: Valve
  • Developer: Valve
  • Release Date: 01/06/2006
  • ESRB Rating: M
  • Official Site: http://orange.half-life2.com/hl2ep1.html

Scores

  • Playability: 7/10
  • Replayability: 6/10
  • Graphics: 8/10
  • Sound: 8/10
  • Overall: 7/10

Recently re-released within Valve’s Orange Box, Half-Life 2: Episode 1 was naturally the first episode released for the greatly acclaimed Half-Life 2 (HL2), followed a year later by the aptly named Episode 2. Episode 1, initially entitled as “Aftermath”, was generally well received by critics. Surely all Valve needed to do was release more content in the style of HL2 for this to be a great game, right?

Fighting alongside the irresistible Alyx
I should start by saying I want to avoid giving away too many spoilers for those who may not have had the chance to try this out yet. Conversely though my first spoiler is there isn’t many. It is of little surprise that you, still playing as the subdued Gorden Freeman, are still alive after the ominous explosion while on top of the Citadel.

You spend the first half of this at most, 6 hour episode, wandering around the mediocre lower citadel levels seen at the end of HL2. There are some decent set pieces, above all fighting alongside the irresistible Alyx, but by and large there seems to be a lack of flair on display. Re-using the same scenery and unimaginative puzzles becomes a tedious and depressing experience; one I was rather hoping would end soon.

Once escaped from the Citadel by means of a stylish set piece, you find yourself back in the war zone that is City 17 itself. The pace barely picks up, mainly thanks to the frustrating scripted scenes with Alyx. Be it not for her unlimited charm, I would quite literally be introducing hopper mines to her elegant contours.

The level design does get a little more enjoyable thanks to the more open feel of being outside, but the general gameplay still fails to make an impression. An example is the repeated use of the gravity gun to push cars into holes, from which infinitely spawning Antlions appear. This is a tedious enough chore on its own, but to have to complete the same routine several times while being constantly attacked is just irritating.

Still after that there is some fun to be extracted, even though this is again somewhat marred by re-using the same locations for most of the time. It’s not until the final slice of this episode which entails an epic encounter that the quality and pace picks up a notch.

Brand spanking new HDR effects
The engine used is essentially identical to the one seen in HL2. This is no bad thing, since the general look and feel can still impress, even if starting to show the signs of aging. The physics are always a joy to play with; most objects can be picked up and hurtling them into anything and everything is still amusing. The animation and facial expressions are still top class, bringing life and emotion into all of it’s characters. The brand spanking new HDR effects seen here are still the best to date, and helps keep the game look modern and easy on the eye.

Gets the heart pacing during the heat of the battle
One aspect easily ignored in the HL2 series is the first-rate voice acting. The script and dialogue hits you with enough emotion to care about Alyx, despite the rest of the games failings. Elsewhere regrettably, there is little to get excited about. Since the majority of the sounds are re-used from the original HL2 it’s largely forgettable. The tempo and style of the music on the other hand still gets the heart pacing during the heat of the battle, which peculiarly provides a welcome respite to the rest of the game.

A good user made mod
You might have sensed an edge of negativity in this review. If you have just said that, don’t expect to get a degree in psychology! Seriously though, don’t let this review put you off trying it. It’s available basically for free inside the assortment king: the Orange Box. The problem I find with this Episode is that for the most part, it’s disappointing. Overuse of scripted scenes with Alyx tends to slow the pace down; too much of a good thing just makes it run of the mill. There is a distinctive lack of new content, and only a peppering of story continuance. In essence the best way to sum up this first expansion is to compare it to a good user made mod.

Pros:

  • Great voice acting
  • Nice new HDR effects
  • Alyx!

Cons:

  • Repetitive gameplay elements
  • Nothing much new
  • Too short

Scores

  • Playability: 7/10
  • Replayability: 6/10
  • Graphics: 8/10
  • Sound: 8/10
  • Overall: 7/10

Comments

Page: 1
evilgiraffeman (1 Month Ago)
I think your review here is pretty justified and there isn't much to seperate the game from a 7 or an 8 in my eyes.

The short game and repetetiveness was annoying but I thought it was a good episode of polished gameplay, even if the story didn't really progress much.

A good review though, you highlight the main points and I think the comparison to a good user made mod is very accurate.
Gunn (LA) (1 Month Ago)
A good review, nice and to the point.

If I ever need a quick fix of Freeman without the full thought of completing the entire game, I may give this a go.

Even if it is to see Alyx!!
Wedgeh (3 Months Ago)
Its short for a reason, its meant to be episodic gaming and under that premise it works well. It wasnt designed to be a full sequel or addon pack but designed to give us just enough fix of freeman until the next episode arrived.

Blame Valve for not getting the time between episode release dates right.

Post A Comment

Login to post a comment